Tourism can be viewed as being a ‘product’.
Tourism products include types of accommodation, attractions, activities, tours, and so on, made available by various different suppliers.
Do not confuse the term tourism product with tourism destination. A tourist destination, such as Christchurch, is a place where many different tourist products may be purchased.
Consumer Perspective Of The Tourism Product
We will first study the tourism product from a consumer (i.e. a tourist) perspective.
According to Collier,
The tourism product is complex in nature and includes everything that the tourist purchases, sees, experiences, and feels from the time he/she leaves home until he/she returns.
The tourism product includes:
- Journey to and from the destination.
- Accommodation and travel while at the destination.
- Everything purchased, including food & beverage, souvenirs, amusement, and entertainment.
- Experiences such as sounds, smells, and interactions with the local population.
- Attractions, activities, amenities, accessibility
- Ancillary services: This refers to all the 'extras' that the tourist may need when going on holiday. They include: travel insurance, foreign exchange, airport parking, equipment hire, passport and visa services.
Each of the above components is a sub-product.
Although a consumer (i.e. a tourist) may buy any of the sub-products separately from various different suppliers or combine some sub-products to create a package holiday, ultimately the consumer sees the tourism product as a total experience.
Also, it must be noted that a bad experience with one sub-product may affect a tourist’s impression of another sub-product and the overall opinion of the tourism product (we will come back to this shortly).
Although a consumer (i.e. a tourist) may buy any of the sub-products separately from various different suppliers, or combine some sub-products to create a package holiday, ultimately the consumer sees the tourism product as a total experience.
As you can see from the above diagram, an individual tourism product is made up of many components which are mainly service based in nature. Consequently, consumers come into contact with many different people during their holidays. People: the human element is very important in the delivery of the overall tourism product because if the tourist receives poor service in one or more areas it takes away from the overall appeal of a tourism product. Experiences and expectations are not directly purchased but will form part of the overall package. If one or two things go wrong, the visitor’s entire experience is tarnished, as the circle is broken.
Reflection
Reflect on a holiday, conference, or tourism experience that a visitor might have in New Zealand. Think of all the tourism professionals that visitors may encounter during their stay.
NB: (a tourism product depends on the roles played by the service personnel, as well as the host population. Two people can purchase the same holiday/transport/accommodation but have completely different experiences).
The interaction with many different people can impact on the consumer’s overall opinion of the tourism product. “The more people that are involved, the greater the risk of something going wrong.” (Collier) There is a possibility that for one or more reasons the tourism product does not meet the consumer’s expectations. The overall satisfaction the consumer gains from a tourism product depends on the roles played by the service personnel, as well as the host population.
As with any service delivery, there is “only one chance to get it right”.
Characteristics Of The Tourism Product
We have said that tourism is a product. In marketing, the term product covers both physical goods, such as a bar of chocolate, and services, such as mowing a lawn. Therefore, we can say that tourism is a service. Services have unique characteristics which pose some challenges when it comes to the task of marketing. In his textbook, Tourism Industry Management, Collier describes these characteristics:
The fact that the tourism product is intangible means that you cannot “try before you buy”. Similarly, you cannot return a service if you are dissatisfied with it, something you can easily do with tangible products. This creates an element of risk for the consumer as he/she will most likely pay in advance for a tourism product and have no guarantee it will meet their expectations.
To reduce the risk and uncertainty associated with purchasing a tourism product a consumer will do two things. Firstly, he/she will seek word-of-mouth recommendations from family and friends. If this is not possible the consumer will have to trust the information sourced from a travel agent, i-site consultant, hotel receptionist, and so on. Secondly, the consumer will look for the physical (tangible) elements associated with the tourism product. This can include photos of the accommodation, the quality of the brochures and leaflets, even the food served, and the appearance of flight attendants on an airplane.
Intangibility:
Intangible is a word we use to describe something you cannot see, touch, or taste. It is something invisible that you experience.
The fact that the tourism product is intangible means that you cannot “try before you buy”. Similarly, you cannot return a service if you are dissatisfied with it, something you can easily do with tangible products. This creates an element of risk for the consumer as he/she will most likely pay in advance for a tourism product and have no guarantee it will meet their expectations.
The consumer buys an intangible product, something that is unable to be used until the time comes about when they travel. They buy in advance with an expectation to satisfy their wants and needs and the reason for such a trip. Where it mentions that the product is composite, it relates to the customer's perception that all events of experiences, expectations, people, and other services that they may use will also give the total experience. If a shopkeeper or salesperson is rude, then the total experience for the entire journey would have disrupted or spoilt their journey.
Perishability:
Perishable describes something that can lose its usefulness and value if not appropriately stored or transported, or if not used within a certain period. Services cannot be produced and physically stored today so that they can be used at some time in the future.
Many components of the tourism product are considered perishable, including food and beverage items, seats in the transportation sector, accommodation rooms, and rental cars parked in the rental company’s yard.
For example, when an aircraft takes off with 20 empty seats or a hotel has 15 unoccupied rooms for a given night, these products are considered perishable as they have not generated any revenue for that period, even though they may be available for future sale and generation of revenue.
Heterogeneity:
If something is heterogeneous it means it consists of a varied range of different parts. We have already said that the tourism product is made up of many parts (sub-products). Another word you could use is variability.
The tourism product is heterogeneous because many different suppliers are involved in supplying small pieces of the overall tourism product. This means it is very difficult to achieve a consistent level of service quality. Unlike physical products which can be manufactured on a production line and can be therefore all identical, no two service experiences will ever be the same.
The one industry concept recognises that the tourism industry is made up of various sectors or sub-industries and that the tourism product is composite and, from the perspective of the traveller, can be viewed as a total experience. This means that the individual suppliers of the various tourism sub-products and services are supplying only portions of the total product, yet the tourist views the product as a whole.Collier, 2011
For example, a tourist returning home from a holiday may have their positive memories of the entire holiday clouded by an encounter with an unfriendly flight crew.
Inseparability:
The production and consumption of tourist services happen at the same time; we cannot separate them.
For example, consider the case of a physical product such as a chocolate bar that is produced in a factory in the absence of the consumer one day but consumed weeks later. The chocolate bar can even be delivered to the consumer. This cannot happen with a service such as a tourism product. The tourism product is produced in the presence of the consumer. Also, it cannot be delivered to the consumer, the consumer must be taken to the tourism product.
Learning Activity: Word Cloud
Produce a Word Cloud that contains words that you associate with this topic: This activity will not only help you remember the meaning of all the words you have covered so far but also make connections with the words, thereby strengthening schema and familiarity.
You can either use a free online platform, such as wordclouds.com. You should be able to paste/type text using a pop-up box to place the words into a Word Cloud.
Post your responses in the Forum, Word Cloud, and share your individual Word Cloud with your fellow online students.
Complete the following seven Interactive questions
Interrelationships
From a supplier point of view, the tourism product consists of three main elements. These are:
- Access to the destination or product:
- Amenities or facilities at the destination:
- Attractions and activities at the destination:
The above three elements are interrelated.
Learning Activity: New Zealand Airports<
Answer the following questions and post your responses in the Forum, New Zealand Airports.
- Name the cities in NZ where you will find an International Airport.
- List as many Airlines that fly into and out of NZ.
- What type of tourism has increased in light of Covid-19?
- List as many domestic Airports as you can.
Then complete the interactive exercise below, and test your knowledge of International carriers flying to destinations around the globe. (You do not need to add this to the forum).
The success and competitiveness of a tourism destination will depend on how well these components link together, to form a product that is demanded by tourists. Let's explore each one in more detail.
Accessibility
Access means getting near something or being able to use something. In a tourism context, it can mean:
The method of completing each of these is via transport.
Although some people will choose to visit a particular tourist destination because it is far away and secluded, most people will seek a destination that is easy to access. The accessibility of a destination depends on:
Getting Around The Destination
Once a tourist reaches a destination, he/she will no doubt want to travel around to do some sightseeing. Transportation within a destination can range from domestic air travel and ground travel such as rail and coach options, along with public transport such as a local bus, and a network of good quality roads with efficient signage for the tourists who wish to hire a car or campervan.
Ease Of Booking
The final consideration in the accessibility of a tourism destination is how easy is it to purchase the actual holiday and/or individual tourism products. Wholesalers, retailers, and other sales consultants play an important role here. In addition, over the years technological advances such as the internet have made it much easier for people to book trips and individual tourism products.
In general, how does accessibility affect the supply of tourism products?
Access is directly related to whether or not it is easy to supply Tourism Products to potential customers. Tourists will not go to a destination where access is not frequent and easy. Mount Cook, for example, being located in a mountainous and isolated area will make the supply of Tourism Products more difficult. Its location will have a direct impact on the attractions and activities offered.
Another example could be if a country’s transportation network is poor, in the sense that rural roads are in a bad state and often lack visible signposts.
Consequently, tourists get lost and become frustrated. The rail network serves most major cities only (which are usually not the actual major tourism destinations) and tickets can be expensive.
Amenities
Amenities are the basic facilities a destination has to offer to tourists. Sometimes referred to as the “pleasantness” of a place, they play an important role in shaping the visitor experience and making the visitor feel comfortable and secure.
Amenities include:
Infrastructure
These are basic facilities that are already in place at the destination to serve the local people. Infrastructure includes roads, electricity supply, water supply, sewerage, waste disposal, communication facilities, airports, harbours, and transportation networks.
Superstructure
This is developed once sufficient infrastructure is in place. It can be developed to serve the local people and/or to serve tourists. Superstructure includes accommodation, food and beverage, entertainment, shopping, and information services like travel agencies, car rental firms, and financial services like currency exchange offices, banks, and so on.
Explore
Explore the Amenities, Services, and Infrastructure page on the; Ministry of Business, Innovation & Employment site for more information.
Tourists do not choose to visit a destination because of its amenities but they may choose not to visit the destination because of its lack of amenities. The quality of the amenities available is another consideration.
Interestingly, sometimes amenities can be attractions in the minds of some tourists. For example, many people travel to Singapore simply to visit shopping malls. Similarly, a tourist may visit a particular city to eat at a famous restaurant.
In general, how do the amenities in a destination affect the supply of the tourism product? Amenities depend on the availability of investment funds and a skilled human resource base. For example, although Aoraki/Mount Cook is a major natural attraction, the Mt Cook village has only limited amenities to service tourists due to a lack of investment in their development and restrictions placed on future development by DOC who control the region.
Amenities available in the area should suit the attractions and activities being supplied.
Attractions And Activities
As previously mentioned, activities are more active attractions, i.e. the tourist has to do some kind of physical activity. Examples of activities include bike/horse riding, tramping, bungy jumping, skiing, skydiving, and so on. The term ‘attraction’ covers both the reason why a person would visit a particular destination and also the specific places/things the tourist can see/do when they are at the destination. In addition, attractions can also include activities, which are active pursuits tourists can participate in once at the destination.
New Zealand is the Adventure Capital of the World, so it's no surprise that there's a vast range of activities to choose from; go bungy jumping, hop on board a jet boat and shoot down winding rivers or enjoy an incredible hike through one of 14 National Parks. New Zealand's majestic mountains also provide for world-class skiing and snowboarding in the winter.AA Travel
But if you're after something a little more sedate, why not relax in one of the natural thermal pools dotted throughout the country or sample the award-winning vino at one of New Zealand's many wineries?
Explore
Explore the 100% Pure NZ website for more attractions and activities.
In general, how do attractions and activities affect the supply of tourism products?
The availability or lack of natural resources and attractions can directly affect supply. For example, the Mount Cook region has numerous natural attractions but Hamilton, by comparison, has limited options to develop as a tourism destination, indeed having little altogether. New Zealand relies heavily on its natural resources in terms of supplying tourism products. Attractions and amenities should complement each other and be in harmony with a destination.
Learning Activity: Domestic Tourism Articles
Review the following two articles:
Domestic tourism: The biggest winners and losers so far
Domestic tourism: Small towns still leading the charge in terms of recovery, research suggests
These questions are meant to provoke discussion and analysis of supply & demand within the regions.
- What regions in New Zealand are regarded as the winners and losers in terms of tourism post-Covid-19?
- Do you agree with the journalist that small towns are still leading the way in terms of recovery?
- How can Auckland CBD turn things around from being “the biggest loser?”
Post your responses in the Forum, Domestic Tourism Articles.
Events
An event is something that is happening at a destination and therefore, attracts people to the destination. For example, you may choose to go to Auckland not because you want to see Auckland but because you want to attend a concert there. Other examples include sporting events such as the Rugby World Cup or exhibitions and festivals such as the World Buskers Festival or World of Wearable Arts. Have a look at what events are taking place in your area.
Tip
A useful website to see what events are taking place around New Zealand is Eventfinda.co.nz.
Tourism, like any business, involves the marketing and sale of a product. There are many factors influencing the ability to supply a tourism product. These factors include the natural resource base, market factors, consumer demand and competitor activity, investment requirements, government policy, and the Tourism 2025 & Beyond report.
We will now examine each of these factors in the context of supplying New Zealand as a tourist destination. Of course, these factors also influence the supply of individual tourism products within New Zealand.
The Natural Resource Base
New Zealand’s tourism industry primarily depends on natural resources and its “100% Pure New Zealand”.
New Zealand is perceived as having an ‘untouched environment’, where the air is among the least polluted in the world. This perception, along with New Zealand’s spectacular natural beauty is a unique selling point (USP), that is unmatched when compared to other international destinations. Tourism in New Zealand relies on us maintaining the pristine environment, stunning scenery, and indigenous culture that sets New Zealand apart. We attract visitors from all corners of the globe and ensure that we provide quality and sustainable travel experiences.
Important
Let’s go back to the TNZ website and look at some of the Active considerer's reports: Analysis of the size of Tourism New Zealand’s target audience in various markets and their sentiment towards travelling to New Zealand.
- Read more about the International market
- More about Asia (China and Japan)
Notice how “ clean & unpolluted” is still an attractive factor for visitors from China and Japan to New Zealand. (The five other countries, including Australia, are the top competitors).
Page 4: Kantar Active Considerer (AC) Monitor, Asia Key Markets: July-December 2022.
Notice how NZ, Australia and Hawaii are ranked the highest for Landscapes and scenery.
Page 22: Kantar Active Considerer (AC) Monitor, Asia Key Markets: July-December 2022.
Market Factors
A market is a group of actual or potential customers. It is also a place whereby buyers and sellers come together to make an exchange.
Why New Zealand?
What sets New Zealand apart is the relatively untouched realness of our people, culture, lifestyle, environment and landscape.
These 4 key aspects and the way uniquely express New Zealand are central to the very special New Zealand experience. Travellers want to experience, up close, all these aspects of New Zealand and New Zealand travel experiences.
The Unique New Zealand Experience
People
- Friendly
- Casual
- Responsive
- Genuine
Culture and Lifestyle
- New Zealand culture of today
- Living and lifestyle
- NZ indigenous experience
Environment
- Clean and pristine
- Air, water, spaces
Landscape
- Grand/bold
- Contrasting
- Untouched
- New, fresh
A market is a group of actual or potential customers. To use some economic terms, the market is where demand and supply meet.
What is the demand and supply of tourism?
The requirement for tourism products (goods and services) at a place or market is known as tourism demand. The provision of tourism products at a given place or market is known as tourism supply.
Important
Review this article which further explains The Demand and Supply in the Tourism industry.
TNZ also states, “As a marketing organization, TNZ’s role is to generate and shape tourism demand. Through our work, we seek to influence the quality of international and domestic tourism for the long-term benefit of New Zealand. The greater the proportion of visitors in New Zealand who have been influenced by TNZ’s marketing to dream, plan and book their holidays, the better the economic, social, cultural and environmental outcomes to New Zealand, and New Zealanders”.
We will now briefly look at how two market factors, consumer demand and competitor actions, can influence the supply of New Zealand as a tourism product.
Consumer Demand
Just like with any business venture, the success of a tourism product, such as Destination New Zealand, depends on identifying and understanding consumer needs and demand, and then, satisfying that demand to meet or exceed consumer expectations.
Consumer demand can be defined as “what the consumer is willing and able to pay for”. Consumers will almost always purchase products or services that they perceive as being best able to satisfy their needs.
The success of Destination New Zealand depends on providing visitors with a ‘World Class experience in New Zealand. This will mean they will be likely to return for a second visit and/or will recommend New Zealand as a destination to friends and family.
Tourism New Zealand conducts a lot of research to establish the needs, wants and demands of visitors to New Zealand. It publishes a lot of statistics and reports to educate the individual suppliers within the tourism industry. In this way, the suppliers of all of the sub-products can work together to satisfy consumer demand.
Competitors Actions
For New Zealand to sustain its competitive edge in attracting tourists to this country, it must remain up to date with the marketing campaigns of its main competitors, especially those nearby such as Australia, Fiji, and other Pacific Island countries. This requires continuously monitoring the external environment and conducting research on trends in other destinations. In this way, New Zealand will be aware of what its competitors are doing and be ready to respond to their actions.
New Zealand has to ensure that it is not offering the same, or a similar ‘tourist product’, as its competitors are offering. It must highlight the main points of difference that make New Zealand a unique destination.
Bungy jumping in Queenstown is one of the attractions on the adventure tourism trail.
Reading
Go back to TNZ and explore Mindsets at the following link:
https://www.tourismnewzealand.com/insights/mindsets/#/
Mindsets overview: We have prioritised a few mindsets to align our focus. These mindsets have a high desire for travel to or within Aotearoa, are resilient to the changing travel landscape and will contribute positively to New Zealand’s natural environment, culture, society and economy”
For New Zealand to sustain its competitive edge in attracting tourists to this country, it must remain up to date with the marketing campaigns of its main competitors, especially those nearby such as Australia, Fiji, and other Pacific Island countries. This requires continuously monitoring the external environment and conducting research on trends in other destinations. In this way, New Zealand will be aware of what its competitors are doing and be ready to respond to their actions.
New Zealand has to ensure that it is not offering the same, or a similar ‘tourist product’, as its competitors are offering. It must highlight the main points of difference that make New Zealand a unique destination.
Investment - Government Policy
Click on the two headings below to explore more.
Tourism is a capital-intensive business which means it needs a lot of money for it to grow as an industry. Investment is needed for the planning and management of tourism strategies, in addition, to the:
- Development of infrastructure and superstructure
This includes investment in roads, water supplies, managing wastewater, public toilets, signage, car parks and availability of broadband
There must be an investment to meet the growing visitor demand
- The operation and maintenance of facilities
- The promotion of the tourism product
- Research
- Investment in tourism needs to come from both the government (central and local) and private businesses.
The role of the central government in tourism investment requirements includes:
- The central government’s role in facilitating the growth and management of tourism has expanded since 2001.
- This includes ongoing investment in national marketing through Tourism New Zealand, the establishment of a Ministry of Tourism in 2002, development of the Core Tourism Data Set, and support for research, events, and tourism–focused MajorRegional Initiatives.
- Several business assistance programmes have been introduced. There has also been a focus on the development of tourism planning tools for local government, including a Tourism Flows Model, and grant assistance to rural communities faced with major water and wastewater infrastructure pressures resulting from tourism growth.
The New Zealand government is well aware of how important tourism is as an industry in New Zealand. Consequently, it helps the supply of tourism products by investing heavily in the development of tourism. The New Zealand Tourism report called Unlocking The Future of Tourism–Views from New Zealanders, Jan 2021 is evidence of this.
The government wants tourism growth to be productive, sustainable, and inclusive. Their goals are:
- Tourism supports thriving and sustainable regions
- Tourism sector productivity improves
- New Zealand-Aotearoa delivers exceptional visitor experiences
- Tourism protects, restores, and champions New Zealand Aotearoa's natural environment, culture and historic heritage
- New Zealanders’ lives are improved by tourism
Reading
On the Beehive. govt website, the Tourism Minister regularly posts new articles – have a read.
Government involvement does not just come in the form of direct monetary investment in tourism. The government can also influence the supply of tourism in other ways, such as the creation of an economic environment that encourages and enables investment, along with the absence of political uncertainty.
Government policies will change from time to time, depending on whatever political party is charged with running the country. Each government policy created will have an impact of some kind on tourism in New Zealand.
Specific government directives can come in the form of legislation.
Conservation Act 1987
This Act promotes the conservation of New Zealand’s natural and historic resources and designated specific areas to be kept for conservation purposes. It assigns a number of functions to the Department of Conservation(DOC). These include:
- The management for conservation purposes of all land and natural and historic resources held under the Conservation Act
- The preservation of indigenous freshwater fisheries (so far as is practicable)
- The protection of recreational freshwater fisheries and freshwater fish habitats
- Conservation Advocacy
- Promotion of the benefits of international cooperation on conservation matters
- Promotion of the benefits of the conservation of natural and historic resources in New Zealand, the subantarctic islands, the Ross Dependency and Antarctica
- The provision of educational and promotional conservation information
- Fostering recreation and allowing tourism on conservation land, providing the use is consistent with the conservation of the resource
- Provision of advice to the Minister.
Resource Management Act 2020
The purpose of this Act is to promote the sustainable management of natural and physical resources. In this Act, sustainable management means managing the use, development, and protection of natural and physical resources in a way, or at a rate, which enables people and communities to provide for their social, economic, and cultural well-being and for their health and safety while:
- sustaining the potential of natural and physical resources (excluding minerals) to meet the reasonably foreseeable needs of future generations
- safeguarding the life-supporting capacity of air, water, soil, and ecosystems
- avoiding, remedying, or mitigating any adverse effects of activities on the environment
Case Study: Supply Of Destination Manawatu
Natural Resources
Manawatu has many natural resources that offer tourists a range of activities. These include the following.
- Ruahine and Tararua Ranges – used for hiking, hunting, hang gliding
- Manawatu Gorge – used for kayaking
- Himitangi and Tangimoana beaches – used for boating and fishing
- Manawatu River – used for boating and fishing
- Apiti Wind Farm – Has a viewing area beneath a turbine
- Victoria Esplanade – mini train rides for kids at weekends and on holidays
Accommodation and TOURISM
A diverse range of accommodation is available in the region targeted mainly at the business, conference and family markets. However, due to the limited natural and man-made attractions in the area investment in large-scale tourism projects has been limited. Despite the fact that the area is very accessible with good road access, rail links to Wellington and an airport with international capacity, there are few opportunities for investment to develop large-scale tourism facilities. The area is heavily reliant on the educational and agriculture sectors and most investment is directed towards those industries, rather than tourism.
Tourism and funding
Destination Manawatu is a regional tourism organisation that has made a commitment to the Going Greener programme run by the Palmerton North City Council. This is consistent with the sustainability objectives of the Tourism 2025 & Beyond strategy. The region benefits from government funding of education through Massey University, which generates educational tourism, conferences and visits by extramural students for on-campus lectures. UCOL and the International Pacific College are additional educational facilities that assist the local economy and draw visitor traffic.
There are major military facilities in the region, Linton Army Camp and Ohakea Air Base that bring government funding to the region and provide significant economic activity and some visitor traffic.
Tourism and competitors
The main markets for the region are educational, conference, and sporting groups together with the VFR market. This type of tourism market means that visitor travel is spread relatively evenly through the year and is not subject to the seasonality that affects some other regions. There is not a lot of international visitor traffic due to the region’s proximity to Wellington.
The major competitors for the region include Wellington with its harbour, culture and entertainment options. The Ruapehu/Taupo region with skiing, volcanic activity and diverse landscapes. Hawkes Bay, with its art deco buildings, wineries and coastline. All of these competitor destinations are little more than a two-hour drive away from Palmerston North and offer a greater range of attractions and activities than Manawatu.
Learning Activity: Case Study-Supply Of Destination Manawatu
Reflect on the case study above. What do you consider to be the strengths of this region from a supply/demand perspective? What do you consider to be the weaknesses?
Post your response on the Forum, Case Study-Supply Of Destination Manawatu.
Demand and supply is an economic concept. In a marketplace, what is produced or offered (supply) should be equal to what is demanded. Without the demand for tourism products, services, and destinations there would be no point in supplying them. Just like with any business venture, the success of a tourism product, service or destination depends on identifying and understanding consumer demand and satisfying that demand.
The economic definition of demand is: “what the consumer is willing and able to pay for”. Consumers will almost always purchase products or services which they perceive as being best able to satisfy their needs.
In our study of demand, we will look at the following factors:
- Consumer behaviour (tourists and travellers)
- Motivating factors, facilitating factors, and resistance factors
- Motivational theories effect of fluctuations in price
- The effect of fluctuations in price
- The effect of changes in demand
Consumer Behaviour
When consumers/tourists are thinking of purchasing a tourism product service or visiting a particular destination, many factors influence them. You just have to look at peoples’ different tastes, ages, and incomes to see that there are so many differences in their lives and therefore, there will be many different purchasing decisions. Market research, visitor surveys, and keeping a close watch on changing global trends are increasingly important.
Important
A great source of information is The Tourism Strategy Group at the Ministry of Economic Development, which is “responsible for the provision of quality information, research and forecasts to meet the needs of a wide range of tourism sector users”.While on this website, go to Tourism Data Releases, and click on International Visitor Survey. The International Visitor Survey (IVS) measures the expenditure, characteristics, and behaviours of international visitors to New Zealand. Then click on the tourism evidence and insights centre. There you will find the 2 June 2023 International Visitor Survey.
You can download this PDF.
Have a look at these infographics on why visitors are spending and their satisfaction results.
The suppliers of tourism products need to carry out market research to answer questions such as:
- Are you looking to attract domestic visitors (fellow Kiwis) or international visitors?
- What regions of New Zealand or what countries do they come from?
- What is their average daily expenditure when holidaying?
- How do they pre-purchase their travel and activities?
- Do they use a travel agency? Go online? Or do they ring and book direct with the operator after they've arrived?
- What is their average age?
- Do they travel in organised tour groups or independently?
- How many days do they spend in your region?
- When do they visit your region?
- What activities do they do?
- Where do they stay?
- How do they travel while in New Zealand?
- Do they speak English, or will they need assistance in their language?
If the answers to these questions can be found, the tourism supplier/marketer will have a sound understanding of their consumers and therefore, a huge competitive advantage.
We must satisfy consumer demand by providing our visitors with a “World Class” tourism experience in New Zealand. To ensure this, we must find out what our tourist market needs and wants so that we can better meet or even exceed their expectations.
Important
Market research, visitor surveys, and keeping a close watch on changing global trends is increasingly important. A great source of information is The Tourism Strategy Group at the Ministry of Economic Development, which is “responsible for the provision of quality information, research, and forecasts to meet the needs of a wide range of tourism sector users”.
The Process Of Establishing And Satisfying Needs
One way to understand consumer behaviour is to study the process by which people establish and satisfy needs. This is an element of the decision-making process, which is a generic marketing activity that can be easily applied to purchasing a tourism product.
This process is illustrated in the following diagram. The traditional decision-making model is represented using solid lines and the process of satisfying needs is signified by the broken lines.
Need Arousal
This is when a need is stimulated. For example, if you have not eaten all day your stomach will rumble. You will notice a ‘gap’ between what you have and what you want. In other words, something is missing, for example, you will feel hungry. Factors/stimuli that could arouse a need for travel and tourism products, i.e. a holiday?
- You are tired of routine and want something new
- You feel the need to re-energise after a cold winter, difficult job, life stress, etc.
- You feel the need to adjust your state of mind
Need Awareness
This is when you become conscious of how you could address your needs. For example, if you are hungry, you will become aware that you need to eat something; you need food.
From a tourism point of view, need awareness can be:
- The need to meet new people
- The need to learn about something new
- The need for some sun and relaxation
- The need for adventure and personal growth
Motivation To Act
Now that you are aware of a need that you would like to satisfy the next stage is motivation to act. In other words, you are encouraged to move forward to try to satisfy that need. In our example of being hungry and needing food, you will be motivated to go out and look for a food source, you might visit a local café for example. What could motivate you to act on the need to go on a holiday? Could it be?
- A conversation with a friend about a recent holiday they have taken
- The awareness of an event that you want to attend
- Advertising that meets your needs for sun/a break/relaxation etc
- A change in life circumstances that presents the opportunity to travel
Motivation is quite a difficult thing to analyse as it is a psychological influence; it’s all in the mind of the consumer. We will look closely at motivation in the upcoming section on motivational theories and travel motivators.
Purchase Decision
Once you have shopped around and put some thought into your options you will then decide on what tourism product will best meet your needs. The decision to purchase demonstrates your commitment to addressing the needs that have been aroused. In making the decision you will consider your options and make a choice. Your decision will involve a specific plan such as the place, time, and costs involved. For example, deciding what items to order from the menu in the café and whether you will eat straightaway or get a meal to takeaway.
Learning Activity: Tourism Product
What factors would influence your decision to purchase a specific tourism product?
Then think of a tourism product you purchased in the past. Your decision was probably in response to satisfying established needs.
Consider the process you went through in the following table (it might be easier to start at the end). Use this table to complete the activity and post it on the forum: here is an example.
Need arousal | I am tired, bored, and fed up with the monotonous routine of daily life |
Need awareness | I realised I needed to get away to get some sun |
Motivation to act | I have been invited to a wedding in Motueka, and I have holidays from work. I have researched the location on the Internet of the surrounding area, which showed beautiful beaches. Chatting with friends, I learned about what to do in the area, as I had never been there before. |
Purchase decision | Two-week holiday to Motueka and Nelson region |
Think of a tourism product you purchased in the past. Your decision was probably in response to satisfying established needs. Consider the process you went through. This table is a good example, but you need to complete your own. (it might be easier to start at the end). Post your own completed table on the Forum, Tourism Product.
Reflection
Reflect on the process by which people establish and satisfy needs in terms of purchasing a tourism product. How would the following videos help sway your decision?
Florida Travel: Welcome to the Great Calusa Blueway Paddling Trail (1:56)
Royal Caribbean: Seeker Spotlight (2:08)
SeaTrek Vietnam: Walking Underwater Tour (3:05)
Switzerland Dream now - travel later (0:29)
Motivational Theories
Many theories have been written on motivation to understand human behaviour. Some of them can be related to the demand for tourism. We will study three such theories.
- Maslow
- Gray
- Ramumbo
Maslow - Hierarchy Of Needs
Abraham Maslow was an American psychology professor. He devised a hierarchy of needs and this is often depicted in a pyramid-shaped diagram.
Watch this video
It is on Maslow's Hierarchy of Needs. (2:25)
Maslow's Hierarchy of Needs
The hierarchy implies that the most basic needs are at the bottom and that each need must be satisfied before moving on to the next one above it, but now it is recognised that the pyramid model can be fluid and needs overlap. The basis of Maslow's theory is that we are motivated by our needs as human beings. Additionally, if some of our most important needs are unmet, we may be unable to progress and meet our other needs. This can help explain why we might feel "stuck" or unmotivated. It's possible that our most critical needs aren't being met, preventing us from being the best version of ourselves possible. Changing this requires looking at what we need, and then finding a way to get it.
However, some criticise Maslow's hierarchy of needs on the basis that our needs don't always exist in a pyramid format, or that one need is more important than another. There's also a concern that his idea of self-actualization cannot be tested. Others suggest that Maslow's theory is weak because it was based on research that was misattributed or lost the original concept being studied.
Taken from: https://www.verywellmind.com/what-is-maslows-hierarchy-of-needs-4136760 (You can read more on this website, to aid a better understanding.
According to Principles of Tourism, 8th edition (Collier, 2011) the link between these needs and tourism is:
Level | NEED | EXPLANATION | IMPLICATION FOR TOURISM |
---|---|---|---|
1st | Physiological | Most basic needs Needed for human survival e.g. air, food, water, sleep, clothing, shelter |
Individuals at this stage do not generally get involved in tourism E.g. people who only travel because they are refugees, nomads, or border workers |
2nd | Security | Once basic, physical needs are satisfied people become concerned with their own personal security, being safe e.g. personal safety, health, and wellness, free from harm/threats, financial security |
Evidenced by those who prefer to travel in groups or on an escorted tour Also related to the choice of destination e.g. travelling to a country that has no perceived threats, is politically stable |
3rd | Social | Once people’s basic needs are satisfied and they feel safe and secure then the next need to be satisfied is that of social belonging e.g. family, friendship, love, affection, belonging to a group |
Travelling in groups with family and friends 18- 30s, Golden Age, cruise tourism products |
4th | Esteem | The next need is to be accepted and valued by others, having skills/knowledge/talents recognised and respected E.g. self-esteem, self-respect, achievement |
Travel is considered to be a status symbol Maybe a need to ‘keep up with the Joneses” |
5th | Self-actualisation | Become your best; achieve your full potential “Find yourself” |
Moved past the need to socialise/impress with choice of holiday, instead travel for a purpose such as a conference or meeting |
Gray - Wanderlust & Sunlust
Professor H.P. Gray believed that the main motivation to engage in pleasure travel is the desire to be elsewhere and to escape, however temporarily, from the routine constraints and stresses of everyday life.
According to Gray’s theory, the motivation for pleasure travel (tourism)could be divided into two parts: “two separate and distinct motivational forces”.
The first motivation is Wanderlust. It is the desire to exchange the known for the unknown, to leave familiar things and to seek new experiences, places, peoples and cultures.
The second motivation is Sunlust, which according to Burkart and Medlik (1974), “generates a type of travel which depends on the existence elsewhere of better amenities for a specific purpose than are available in the domicile. It is prominent with particular activities such as sports and literally with a lust for the sun”
(According to the Oxford Languages, the word “Domicile” means “the country that a person treats as their permanent home or lives in and has a substantial connection with”).
The two motivations are often interdependent. Most tourism products contain elements of both Wanderlust and Sunlust.
Watch this video
It is from the BBC, questioning why some people have Wanderlust and not others. (3:37)
Ramumbo - Four Travel Motivators
Cuebro Ramumbo, a Mexican social scientist, wrote a theory based on Maslow’s hierarchy of needs. He divided basic travel motivators into four categories.
According to Principles of Tourism, 8th edition (Collier, 2011) these include:
Travel Motivator | Explanation |
---|---|
Physical | Related to rest, participation in sports, and recreation generally. So, they are directly connected with the person’s bodily health. Linked to Health, Spa and Nature tourism. |
Cultural | Identified by the desire of the traveller to learn about other countries and their art, music, dances, traditions, food, religion, lifestyle, etc. Many travellers, the Japanese in particular, travel to satisfy their curiosity about other cultures, lifestyles, and places. Linked to Cultural & Heritage tourism |
Interpersonal | Create a desire to meet new people, visit friends & relatives, and get away from the routine of everyday life. Or simply to ‘escape’. |
Status and prestige | Related to needs of esteem and personal development. Such motivations as the desire for recognition, attention, power, and appreciation, and doing what’s fashionable. Even the desire for sexual attractiveness can be satisfied through travel. |
Motivating, Facilitating, and Resistance Factors
There are three main factors that influence the demand for tourism and travel to and within a destination. Motivating, Facilitating, and Resistance. Let's view these in detail.
Motivating Factors
These are the psychological reasons for travel which sit behind the basic purpose for travel. Travel motivators may include but are not limited to:
- To see how people in other countries live, work and play
- To see particular sights
- To gain an understanding of what goes on in the news
- To attend special events
- To get away from everyday routine
- To have a good time
- To achieve some sort of romantic experience
- To visit places, one’s family came from
- To visit places, one’s family or friends have gone to
- To experience particular weather (perhaps to avoid winter)
- To improve health (sunny, dry climate, clean air)
- To engage in a sport (to swim, fish, sail, golf)
- To go on an adventure (new area, people, experiences)
- One-upmanship Conformity (keeping up with the Joneses)
- To participate in history (ancient and current)
For example, the purpose of a holiday is to visit family and friends but the reason (motivation) for this is to satisfy your social needs (see Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs).
The four main categories are:
- Visit friends/family
- Vacation/holiday
- Education
- Business
You may have seen the above list printed on a passenger arrival card at the airport. It is very easy for tourists to tick a box and state their purpose of travel. However, is more difficult to understand the real reasons behind their trip, i.e. what motivated them to come here, and what needs were they trying to satisfy.
Facilitating Factors
Facilitating factors are things that make it easy for a person to become involved in travel and tourism such as:
- Time (leisure time) - Legislative intervention (leading to such innovations as paid holidays) created a demand for tourism in the 19th century commensurate with the increase in available leisure time. Leisure time includes after-work hours, weekends, and annual holidays. New Zealanders engage mostly in New Zealand domestic travel over weekends. And both domestic and international travel over the long holiday periods. With a trend to longer working hours and company downsizing with reduced staff benefits it is likely that shorter, more frequent holidays will become the norm amongst New Zealand travellers.
- Money (disposable income) - the growth of tourism in the 19th century was due to the Industrial Revolution and the creation of a wealthy middle class who had the requisite disposable income to devote to leisure pursuits.
The destination is also another main facilitating factor in terms of price competitiveness and marketing expenditure.
In addition to disposable income and leisure time, there are many other factors facilitating travel. These include:
- Availability of transport to and within the destination
- Accommodation at the destination – people need a place to stay
- Political stability – people will be discouraged from travelling to areas of socio-political instability
- Accepted mediums of exchange (foreign exchange) – not being able to obtain a currency freely negotiable in the destination country can make travel to that destination less attractive
- Access to travel documentation – travel is hindered if visas and/or passports are costly or difficult to obtain
- Social factors (see below)
The social factors which facilitate travel include:
- Early retirement coupled with a greater life expectancy
- Labour force changes such as a shorter working week create more leisure time
- Greater mobility in all age groups and a wider acceptance of travel as a leisure pursuit
- Smaller families
- Transport improvements and cost decreases – particularly in the highly competitive Low-Cost Airline environment
In New Zealand, Domestic Tourism, facilitators include:
- Ease of access to most locations, with relatively short distances involved
- No currency exchange rate considerations arise
- Discounted fares continue to become more readily available in a vigorous competitive airline environment
- Time for short breaks over weekends, public holidays
From the perspective of overseas people visiting New Zealand, these could be some facilitating factors.
- Regular and expanding international air services exist from most generating markets
- Historically, currency exchange rate advantages exist for most foreign visitors
- There is a widely accepted perception of safety and ease of travel to and within New Zealand for overseas visitors
- Few extraordinary entry requirements exist, with New Zealand being a visa-free destination for most passport holders
Resistance Factors
Resistance factors are things that will put people off travelling or take away from the attractiveness of a tourism destination or product. These may include:
- Time and money constraints
- Distance, location (ease of access), cost
- Relative prices of goods and services compared to the country of residence
- Foreign exchange rate
- Political instability and associated safety concerns (civil unrest)
- Climate variance, natural disasters
- Lack of amenities
- The overall image of the destination country
- Host population attitudes toward visitors
- Language barriers, airport congestion, etc
- Fear of flying
- Family commitments
- Work commitments
Considering domestic travel within New Zealand, these could be resistance factors.
- Cost
- Time involved
- Competing demands for disposable income, such as conventional consumer items
- The attraction of particularly short-haul overseas travel as an alternative to domestic travel
From the perspective of overseas people visiting New Zealand, these could be resistance factors.
- Distance and related higher relative cost
- For many prospective travellers, New Zealand is considered a remote destination
- Time required to travel greater distances
- Seasonal considerations – particularly for Northern Hemisphere residents
- Language difficulties – particularly for non-English speakers
- Environmental concerns related to carbon emissions as an end-product of air travel
Learning Activity: Travel to New Zealand
Answer the following questions in your own words, and then post them to the Forum, Travel to New Zealand.
- Consider domestic travel within New Zealand. List four (4) resistance factors.
- From the perspective of overseas people visiting New Zealand, what are the six (6) facilitating factors?
Then complete the 8 interactive questions below.
Case Study: Demand For Destination Manawatu
Visitor Demographics
Given the nature of tourism in the region, it is heavily influenced by domestic travel. VFR, sports, conferences, and education are the main reasons for travel.
According to the New Zealand Commercial Accommodation Monitor, international guests account for only 10.2 per cent of all guest nights in the Manawatu RTO area. Domestic visitors are more likely to come from the Wellington, Auckland, Hawkes Bay, Waikato, Hawkes Bay, and Canterbury regions.
The age profile for international visitors is shown in the following graph:
The age profile for domestic visitors is shown in the following graph:
Motivating And Facilitating Factors
Education, sport, business, and VFR travel are the principal motivating factors for travel to the Manawatu region. Holiday and Leisure travel is not a major motivator for visits to the area. Facilitators include a very good road network to and around the region, a rail link to Wellington, regular air services to and from Wellington, Auckland, Hamilton, and Christchurch, together with international air service capacity at the airport.
Resistance Factors
A lack of outstanding natural attractions and significant man-made attractions have given the region a reputation of being somewhat less exciting compared to other areas. The closure of Freedom Air means Australian travellers no longer have direct access to the region and must now travel via Auckland or Wellington. The frequent closure of the Manawatu Gorge road may result in some people avoiding that route.
Changes In Demand
The loss of air services provided by Freedom Air and more recently Origin Pacific will have affected demand for services at Palmerston North Airport, such as duty-free, café services, and taxis. There may well have been flow-on effects for the accommodation industry, rental cars, and transport services to other towns in the region and neighbouring regions.
If there was a government decision to downgrade or diminish the level of educational services provided at Massey University there would be an impact across the local economy, including all the amenities that support the local visitor industry e.g. accommodation, cafes, transport, conference and sporting facilities, etc.
Price And Its Influence On Demand
The price of travel and tourism, i.e. the cost to the consumer of purchasing a tourism product can be either a facilitating or a resistance factor. For example, if the overall cost is perceived as being good value for money, then consumers will be more likely to demand the product.
The price of travel and tourism is said to have three components:
- The price of getting to the destination (transport, accessibility)
- The price of ground costs (whilst at the destination)
- In the case of international travel, the rate of exchange (currency) between the country of departure (generating country) and the host destination
The components of the price will fluctuate daily and will directly affect the demand for tourism products, such as New Zealand as a tourism destination.
Transportation Costs
International visitors can get to New Zealand in two ways; they can fly here by airplane or stop off whilst on a cruise. Most visitors arrive by airplane, so the cost of airfares is very important here. If the cost of air travel increases, we would see a direct impact on the demand for New Zealand as a tourism destination – there would be a decrease in demand.
Low transportation costs (airfares) = high demand for New Zealand as a tourism destination
Ground Costs
These are the cost of all the goods and services the consumer buys whilst at the destination, the price of accommodation, entry fees to attractions and the price of activities, the cost of food and beverage, and so on.
Ground costs generally increase every year, this is known as inflation. If the rate of inflation is high, it means prices are going up quickly. As the price of goods and services increases the demand for them decreases. In New Zealand, the government and the Reserve Bank work hard to maintain price stability. They try to keep inflation between 1.5 – 3% in the medium term.
Low ground costs = high demand for New Zealand as a tourism destination.
Exchange Rates
When international visitors come to New Zealand, they need to exchange their money for New Zealand dollars. The rate of exchange will determine how much money international visitors have to pay to get to New Zealand (airfares) and how much money they will have to spend once they are in New Zealand (to pay for ground costs).
For example, imagine a tourist from England who wants to visit New Zealand. If the New Zealand dollar is weak in comparison to the UK pound sterling the Englishman would be quite well off in New Zealand, he would have plenty of money to spend and would consider the price of goods and services to be cheap. A high New Zealand dollar in comparison to other countries would have the opposite effect.
The low value of NZ$ = high demand for New Zealand as a tourism destination.
Tip
Visit http://www.xe.com/ to find the most recent rates of exchange.
Seasonality
Another factor to consider when examining the fluctuations in the price of travel and tourism and its impact on demand is seasonality. There will of course be times of the year when it is more economical for tourists to visit New Zealand. Demand is higher in peak times so we would expect the process to be high at this time. Demand is low in off-peak times so lower prices and special offers are common.
Key messages from MBIE on the Season dispersal of visitors:
International arrivals in New Zealand are highly seasonal. Arrivals in the summer season are twice the number in the winter season. The pattern of arrivals is relatively similar over the last three years, with recent growth in holidaymakers seen in the autumn season.
- An increasing proportion of holidaymakers are arriving in the summer and autumn seasons, with a lower proportion in the winter season. Seasonal patterns for other visitors (with the purpose of visit being visiting friends or relatives, and business reasons) have remained static.
- Business travellers have a different seasonal pattern. Business arrivals are almost equally spread across all seasons, with slightly more arrivals during spring and autumn seasons, and the least arrivals during summer.
- People in different age groups show different seasonal travel patterns. Although the majority of visitors prefer to visit during summer, older travellers are more likely to travel in shoulder seasons (especially autumn).
- People from different countries show different degrees of seasonality. These travel patterns are unchanged across multiple years.
- People from all countries (apart from India and Indonesia– their peak season is autumn and winter respectively) show a strong tendency to visit during summer rather than in winter. However, in certain countries, such as China, holidaymakers almost equally prefer to visit in the autumn shoulder season.
Reading
Read more about the seasonal dispersal of International tourists in this report by the mbie.govt.nz here.
Learning Activity: New Zealand Travel & Tourism
Analyse how fluctuations in the components of the price of travel and tourism affect the demand for New Zealand as a tourist destination. Please reference your sources.
Post your response in the Forum, New Zealand Travel & Tourism.
Changes in Demand and its Knock-On Effects
When the demand for a particular tourism product, or service changes for one reason or another, it will have a knock-on effect on the demand for other related tourism products, or services.
We can examine this effect using another economic concept, substitute, and complementary products.
Substitute products are those which can be substituted for one another. In other words, you can use one instead of the other to satisfy the same basic need. Common examples are butter and margarine, or a pen and pencil.
If the demand for one substitute product increases there will be a decrease in the demand for the other product, and vice versa.
People may choose to spend their money on things other than tourism products. Similarly, if they do want to purchase a tourism product there are often many similar alternatives, choices. For example, a UK tourist may choose to visit Australia instead of New Zealand.
Complementary products are those which are usually consumed or used together. Common examples are bread and butter or paper and a pen.
When the demand for one product increases the demand for the other product will also increase, and vice versa.
Sub-products of the overall tourism product, i.e. transportation, accommodation, attractions, and activities are complements. A change in the demand for one sub-product will directly affect the demand for the others. For example, a concert in town means the demand for accommodation is up. With regard to substitute products, people may choose to spend their money on things other than tourism products. Similarly, if they do want to purchase a tourism product there are often many similar alternatives, choices. For example, a UK tourist may choose to visit Australia instead of New Zealand.
The Impacts of COVID-19 on New Zealand Tourism
Review the following articles: (Contextual information has been included so that you can place each article against both international and domestic tourism).
Article 1.Covid-19 coronavirus: New Zealand set for domestic tourism boom in January
Where’s the one place you’ve never been to in New Zealand that you really want to see?
The number of New Zealanders travelling around the country could surge in January, according to new modelling on tourism recovery. Tourism New Zealand's future tourism recovery modelling shows the number of Kiwis taking a domestic holiday may jump to 118 percent in January this past year. And if trans-Tasman borders were to open by a "pragmatic estimate" of January 2021, Australian visitors could expand the economy by $1 billion by September next year, the government agency says.
There will be some steps to reopen trans-Tasman travel at the end of this week, as New South Wales and the Northern Territory allow New Zealanders to travel there quarantine-free. Although those coming into New Zealand have to isolate for 14 days at the moment, the Government is working with Australia and the Cook Islands on full quarantine-free bubbles. Tourism New Zealand chief executive Stephen England-Hall said although there are current uncertainties that will dictate whether recovery takes one year or three, the modelling shows demand back at 2019 levels by December 2022, assuming unconstrained supply. "If we have visibility of these variables, we can take action to influence them to have positive outcomes for the country's economic recovery, like the work we are doing to encourage domestic tourism."
The latest Ministry of Business Innovation and Employment domestic visitor spending data from across New Zealand shows that Kiwis are supporting New Zealand's economic recovery by exploring their own country and doing something new. "Although August domestic visitor spending remained flat compared with last year, given Aucklanders were unable to travel for a large part of the month, it is actually an incredibly encouraging result." Domestic visitation in the July school holiday period grew across all regions, in some cases by up to 50 percent compared to the previous year, and the September school holidays will likely see a similar increase, England-Hall said.
Pre-Covid, domestic tourism accounted for 60 percent of tourism's $40.9b contribution to the New Zealand economy. New Zealanders previously spent $9b on overseas travel per year."We're working hard to encourage domestic tourism and capturing this spend will be critical to the sector's recovery," England-Hall said. Before the pandemic, Australia made up the biggest number of visitors to New Zealand and spent more than $2.7b a year, half of that by holidaymakers.
The modelling drew on work by Treasury, the Reserve Bank, and Westpac.
Article 2.Covid-19: Backpacker, hostel bookings plunge again after alert level changes
Those in the backpacking and hostel industry describe it as “dying” due to the Covid-19 pandemic.
Backpacker hostels still struggling to survive the Covid-19 pandemic have seen already scarce bookings cancelled due to the change in alert levels. Owners across the country dropped their prices and moved to more private rooms in a bid to keep their businesses afloat in 2020. Now, with summer drawing to a close and coronavirus back in the community, those in the backpacking and hostel industry describe it as “dying”.
Brett Duncan, who owns Adventure Queenstown Hostel and Adventure Q2 Hostel, and chairman of the New Zealand Hostels Association said he had had a couple of Aucklanders cancel their stays following the region's move to alert level 3, and was sure there would be more.“It’s compounding the trouble we’re already in.” Pre-Covid, his cheapest shared room bed would be $39 a night, but it has now been fluctuating between $21 to $25. He says attention to detail in the industry has come a long way in the past 20 years.“At normal average occupancy – 95 percent – we would need to sell beds at $31 to break even, so we are selling below cost.”
“Supply and demand (or lack of) is forcing some operators to sink rates in search of cash flow, everyone cascades down behind them.” Belinda Hargreaves, who runs Rotorua’s Rock Solid Backpackers and Dusky Lodge in Kaikōura, said she had lost $5500 as a group had postponed its booking because of the level change. Rock Solid Backpackers is sitting at nine percent occupancy when in February it would normally be 100 percent full.
The government's proposed "reset" on tourism - focussing on attracting high net worth visitors - continues to stir up reactions in the industry. At Dusky Lodge, two houses converted from backpackers into a boarding hostel are “keeping us going”, Hargreaves said. She said she had even accepted a stag party staying over the weekend at Rock Solid. “We’re dire. We’re taking anyone we can get right now.”
As the chairman of the New Zealand Hostels Association, Duncan said the industry nationally since June had averaged just 25.5 percent in occupancy. There are more than 20 backpacker hostels on the market – five percent of the total hostels in the country – and he described the industry as “dying”. Since June, the backpacking and hostel industry nationally has averaged just 25.5 percent in occupancy. “There are usually only two to three properties and many more have just closed their doors.”
Summer had also not been the boom the industry was hoping it would be. Duncan said the national hostel occupancy for December was just 30.4 percent. Queenstown itself was 37 percent, something he described as “quite alarming” as it included the Christmas and New Year period. “January’s numbers are not yet available, but I fear they will be the worst we’ve seen yet. I believe January and February will tell the real horror story we’re facing.” Dormitories in backpackers and hostels are not really selling, with Kiwis choosing to stay in private rooms. Even if there is a trans-Tasman bubble in place for winter, Duncan said Queenstown would be one of the few places to benefit before next summer due to the ski fields. “The regions – and most of the rest of the country – will see very little through winter and will need to survive until next summer without Aussie tourists, a big ask for businesses to operate at losses for 21 months.”
Looking ahead to Easter, Duncan said he has two bookings between his hostels so far. “It’s that bad,” he said. Hargreaves said for her 130-bed hostel Dusky Lodge she has just three bookings. For Rock Solid, she has one.
Brett Duncan says backpackers and hostels are no longer the 1980s stereotype of clean and basic. If the Government does not provide any support by the end of March, Duncan said it would be “all over for a lot of people”. He suggested targeted subsidies or even GST returns, while Hargreaves wanted to see some support to pay rent. “We need a strong backpacker sector for when backpackers return,” Duncan said. “Book direct with the accommodation provider, because the online travel agents take 15 percent and in a time of crisis like this, that is a huge amount of money for us. “Kiwi hostels are amongst the highest rated in the world. They are no longer the 1980s stereotype of clean and basic. They’re sustainable and the attention to detail has come a long way in the last 20 years.” Hargreaves had similar thoughts. “If New Zealand loses hostels it’s going to be dire for these larger groups who love staying with us.”
Learning Activity: Tourism Questions
Read and use the first article to answer the following questions. You must use your own words for both questions.
- In terms of supply and demand, how are Kiwis supporting New Zealand’s economic recovery? Include ONE example from the first article to support your answer.
- In terms of supply and demand, what could you say some of the key weaknesses are? (You will need to make some assumptions).
Read and use the second article to answer the following questions. You must use your own words for both questions
- Thinking about backpacking and hostel bookings, how did Covid-19 affect supply? (You will need to make some assumptions).
- Thinking about backpacking and hostel bookings, how did the oversupply and lack of demand in the backpacking and hostel industry affect price and occupancy? Give an example from the article.
Place your completed responses in the Forum, Tourism Questions.
Explore
Additional resources that you may find useful:
Important
During this component, you have learned all about the factors that can influence the supply and demand for tourism products, services, and destinations, as well as what motivates consumers to spend their dollars on a holiday.
This is your chance to review your understanding of the following factors.
- Motivating factors - are the psychological reasons for travel which sit behind the basic purpose for travel
- Facilitating factors - are things that make it easy for a person to become involved in travel and tourism such (leisure) time and money (disposable income).
- Resistance factors - are things which will put people off travelling or take away from the attractiveness of a tourism destination or product.
Domestic Travellers who holiday in New Zealand are motivated to:
- To stay near to or see particular sights of interest.
- To attend special events.
- To get away from the “everyday routine”.
- To have a good time.
- To visit places where ancestors have come from.
- To visit places where family or friends have gone to.
- Location of the accommodation: To experience particular weather (perhaps to avoid winter).
- To improve health (sunny, dry climate, clean air)
- To engage in a sport (to swim, fish, sail, golf) (if this type of accommodation is near the sporting activity)
- To go on an adventure (new area, people, experiences).
- To support sustainability / reduce carbon footprint, as the article mentions that accommodation in NZ is becoming more sustainable.
Domestic Travellers who holiday in New Zealand facilitate:
- The requisite disposable income to devote to leisure pursuits.
- New Zealanders engaging mostly in domestic travel due to Covid-19 closing the borders.
- Shorter, and perhaps more frequent holidays will become “the norm” amongst New Zealand travellers – if restricted only to domestic tourism.
- Ease of access in most locations, with relatively short distances involved across New Zealand.
- No currency exchange rate considerations.
- Time for short breaks over weekends, and public holidays.
- Availability of transport to and within the destination.
Domestic travellers are resistant to:
- Lack of amenities
- “Snap lockdowns” resulting in a sudden change in Alert Levels
- Negative reviews left on social media / sharing websites such as TripAdvisor etc.,
- Host population / local attitudes towards visitors (e.g. fears towards Aucklanders because of snap lockdowns etc.,)
- Climate variance, natural disasters.
- Time and money constraints.
- Distance, location (ease of access/condition of roads.
- Political instability and associated safety concerns (civil unrest, risk of terrorism etc.,)
- Family commitments.
- Work commitments.
Review International Tourism Products, Services and Destinations
This review of material looks at motivating, facilitating, and resistance factors that can impact supply for overseas tourists visiting New Zealand.
Here are some examples.
- Creating or increasing New Zealand “stimuli”. Why? To experience first-hand the unique Māori culture in destinations such as Rotorua etc. Māori cultural attractions in Rotorua include Tamaki Māori Village, Hell’s Gate Geothermal Park, Mitai Māori Village, Te Puia, and Whakarewarewa. (Source: NZ Guide). Attendance at these venues would be useful here, as some examples of visitor feedback etc. Insight linked to the supply and demand trends around these attractions is beneficial too.
- Safety and cleanliness? According to Immigration New Zealand, serious crime rates are lower in NZ than in many other countries etc., NZ is rated in international surveys as one of the world’s most peaceful, least corrupt countries. The 2017 Global Peace Index, which compares 162 countries for the risk of personal violence, rates New Zealand as the world's second safest country just after Iceland. (Source: ImmigrationNZ).
- Facilitating Factors. Regular and expanding international air services exist from most generating markets, or historically, currency exchange rate advantages exist for most foreign visitors.
- Resistance Factors. For many prospective travellers, New Zealand is considered a remote destination, or the time required to travel greater distances, or environmental concerns related to carbon emission.
- Experiences/thrill-seeking i.e. adventure pursuits.
- The climate at certain times of the year i.e. Australians visiting to ski in winter.
- Exploration – i.e. Visit The Great Walks / See more “natural” beauty.
- Specialist Tourism i.e. Culinary Tourism / Sustainable Tourism.
- Visiting Friends and Relatives (VFR).
- Leave home / Take a break from the “everyday” routine.
- Take advantage of good exchange rates for international visitors.
- It may be a “once in a lifetime opportunity” / On a Wishlist / First time travelling to a new country i.e. NZ.
- To attend a conference/event.
Facilitating Factors include:
- Regular and expanding international air services exist from most generating markets.
- Historically, currency exchange rate advantages exist for most foreign visitors.
- There is a widely accepted perception of safety and ease of travel to and within New Zealand for overseas visitors.
- Few extraordinary entry requirements exist, with New Zealand being a visa-free destination for most passport holders.
Resistance Factors include:
- Distance and related higher relative cost.
- For many prospective travellers, New Zealand is considered a remote destination.
- Time required to travel greater distances.
- Seasonal considerations – particularly for Northern Hemisphere residents.
- Language difficulties – particularly for non-English speakers.
- Environmental concerns related to carbon emissions as an end product of air travel.
Review of Module Information
Finally, complete this interactive exercise below.