Services, just like any other business, are required to demonstrate continuous improvement in environmentally sustainable practices and meet legislation demands. For this to occur, a service needs to first look at the systems they have in place for sustainability and design a plan to improve on areas of work practice. This will be captured in the service’s Quality Improvement Plans (QIP).
This needs to be monitored and reviewed to ensure progress is being made. For this to occur, documentation and recording of improvement is necessary to demonstrate and observe progress. All stakeholders, including families and members of the community should be involved in the review process and be provided with opportunities to provide feedback.
The National Quality Framework (NQF) reinforces services’ commitment for continuous improvement to strive for best practice. While the NQF does not prescribe what best practice looks like, it encourages education and care services to draw on a range of current research, theory and understandings about early and middle childhood. This can provide educators with an understanding of best and most suitable practice in the unique and changing context of their service. This is linked to the fourth principle of the NQF: 'Best practice is expected in the provision of education and care services.'
According to the NQF, continuous improvement can be achieved by:
- Continuous self-assessment against the National Quality Standards and the relevant requirements of the National Law and National Regulations.
- The development and implementation of a Quality Improvement Plan (QIP).
- Regular assessment and rating process conducted by the relevant state or territory Regulatory Authority.
By the end of this topic, you will understand:
- How to assess sustainable practices in the workplace
- How to design a plan for ongoing improvements to practice
- How to monitor and review practices
- How to demonstrate collaboration and communication with stakeholders.
There are many methods for assessing how the service is managing environmental systems and working sustainably.
These may include:
- Conducting internal audit on each commodity that uses paper
- Manual estimates
- Power meters
- Measuring by using recycling records to determine the change per month
- Reviewing purchase orders over a period of time
- A comparison of the bills by the energy provider
- Using a waste contractor to weigh the waste amount or calculate by volume
- Getting an external independent audit.
On Little.ly Early Learning Centre’s website you can access a sustainability policy and procedure document as well as a sustainability action plan and audit template. You can find a copy at the Additional Resources.
Every workplace will have competing priorities, including when it comes to sustainability development. The organisation may have mission statements, procedures and policies regarding their priorities for sustainability, just as they have for other areas such as WHS. These support the knowledge and streamlined implementation and awareness of KPIs and targets for sustainable actions and requirements in practice. Depending on the business, different directions may be evident; these might relate to costing procedures, approvals and sales systems.
For example, stage gating systems may be implemented to decide whether the target is related to a particular product, product range or all areas of the business and how the customer or client has driven or encouraged the goals. A stage gating system is a business roadmap that is designed to move a new product or project from idea to launch with breaks or gates in between, where the leadership assess and approve each phase, which may include concept, development, industrialise and launch. In between these stages there will also be costings approvals, where the business will assess the cost vs. benefit of implementing sustainable strategies.
Watch the following 5-minute YouTube video from Planisware to get an overview of the stage gate concept:
- View examples of Green Guides by the Australian Services Union here.
- Access this article by Business.gov to learn how to create an environmentally friendly business.
Another audit practice specific to environmental sustainability is greenhouse gas calculators. These exist to estimate the amount of energy used by a workplace. Measurement examples include:
How much of something in particular does the workplace use? You can identify purchase history or how much is in stock.
You can visually observe the resource and this will tell you about patterns of usage. An example of this could be identifying how many lights are left on at the end of the day.
Waste that is collected or emptied into a bin can be calculated. This could be via weighing the bin or counting the number of products used.
Refer to the different types of calculators available on the Australian Government’s Clean Energy Regulator website.
In summary, an environmental audit is a management system where a tool is used to systematically, objectively and periodically evaluate and document environmental performance in the workplace in line with set outcomes or requirements. This assesses risk, controls and improves areas within the workplace. You might like to create your own audit or self-assessment checklist relating to areas of your business’s environmental impact, using the environmental principles as a guide.
Some questions you might ask about your workplace include:
- What could go wrong (for employees, employers, the workplace or the environment) regarding environmentally responsible practices?
- Are we using the workplace and equipment correctly and in an environmentally responsible way?
- Do we need more training in how to environmentally manage the workplace?
- Do we manage and store chemicals correctly? (Don’t forget, you may need permission to dispose of some chemicals by your local authority, e.g. EPA)
- How can we minimise the chance of harm or potential harm?
Risk minimisation
The standard risk minimisation process is a relevant process to use when assessing the sustainability of a workplace. The EPA (VIC) has provided specific versions relating to the environment.
Download EPA Victoria’s self-assessment tools for controlling risk from the following links:
- 1695.1: Assessing and controlling risk: A guide for business
- 1812.1: Self-assessment tool for small business
Here’s a list of important terms related to risk minimisation:
Risk | This is the threat that a particular hazard poses. This is made up of the likelihood that it could cause harm and consequences, which is what could happen if harm is caused (the outcome—the level or severity) |
Hazards | This is something that has the potential to cause harm |
Receptor | This is what harm can be caused to, for example, people or the environment |
Controls | What is put in place to eliminate or minimise the risk |
Risk matrix | The design to assess the consequences to potential risks |
The EPA reminds us that these control systems are helpful in self-assessing workplace environments:
- Identify any hazards or activities at your business that could cause harm
- Assess how severe the risk is, based on the likelihood of it happening and its consequence
- Implement suitable risk control measures.
- Check controls regularly to make sure they are working.
Consistent measurement, audits and records
It is beneficial to have an environmental management system. This ensures consistency in how processes are conducted. When conducting any measurements of resources, consistency is the key. The same approach, in the same area and environment, should be chosen to ensure consistency.
Data comparison can then be made by assessing usage and comparing it with months, times of the year or other departments, such as using graphs to represent data visually.
Analyse data
Review the data: What does this tell you about areas that need improvement and areas that already have strong sustainable elements connected to their processes? Why is this, do you think?
After collecting data, you should analyse it and review your organisation’s practices and strategies in line with the environmental principles. You may wish to analyse such areas as:
- General waste, hazardous and chemical waste management
- Land requirements
- Energy use
- Vehicle use
- Water use
Here are some examples of audits and templates:
- Mightybytes: ‘Learn how Organizations can Address SDGs in Our New Report
- 'Green Procurement Guideline' Procurement Service SA
- AbsorbTech: ‘50 Ways to be more Sustainable and “go green” at Work’
- City of Melbourne: ‘Waste Management Template’
- Business.gov: Chemical waste checklist
Here are some further resources on supporting your workplaces to become more sustainable:
- CERES: Supplier self-assessment questionnaire (SAQ)
- EPA Victoria: Preventing harm to people and the environment
- Business.gov: How to make your business environmentally friendly
- Recycle coach: 6 examples of sustainability in the workplace (and their impact)
- WA Environmental Protection Authority: Statement of environmental principles, factors and objectives
Audit, analyse and reflect
- Visit the Business.gov website and read about waste management.
- Using the waste management template provided, assess your workplace or another workplace using the information provided for energy management, water management and waste management by the City of Melbourne.
- Using this risk assessment document provided by EPA Victoria (1695.1: Assessing and controlling risk: A guide for business), assess the potential risk of the waste.
- Reflect: With an early childhood education and care service in mind, review the environmental management tips and write down:
- What is your service already doing well from an environmental management perspective?
- What areas need improvement or present a potential risk to the environment? Explain how this links to the Environmental Principles.
Identifying sources and collecting information is the next step in positive, sustainable practices, which can be shared with your workplace.
Further areas for environmental support, products or advice can be found at the following links:
- Australian Conservation Foundation
- Department of Agriculture, Water and the Environment
- Business Council for Sustainable Development Australia
- Eco Office
Practice
Read the following scenario, then try to answer the questions that follow to practise tasks related to an environmental audit, including tracking water usage.
You, Alex, Jamie, Ryan, and Mia are discussing ways to reduce water usage at your workplace, EcoCare Co.
You have reviewed the water bills for the current and previous year, summarised below:
Current year | Previous Year |
---|---|
|
|
Note: Each quarter consists of 91 days. Currently, you're midway through the fourth quarter.
Alex has compiled last year's water bills to compare and identify trends. Jamie is keen on implementing immediate changes to reduce usage. Ryan is exploring long-term solutions, particularly rainwater harvesting systems. Mia is less interested in financial aspects but values environmental sustainability and employee well-being.
Now, try to answer the following questions. You can check your answer for each question by clicking on the 'Answer' button.
Question 1:
What tools can Jamie use to set efficiency targets for water use?
- Water usage audits: Investigate water invoices or receipts from suppliers over a period to determine the centre’s water use. This will provide a baseline of usage information and help identify overall use patterns, including increases, decreases, and seasonal effects.
- Water meters: Install water meters on various parts of the facility (e.g., bathrooms, kitchens, irrigation systems) to measure specific usage. This detailed information can help identify high-use areas and track the effectiveness of water-saving measures.
Question 2:
Considering the data from the service’s water bills as presented, calculate how many kilolitres of water the service uses daily in the current year on average, in all three quarters separately.
- Calculation: 1,900 kL / 91 days = 20.87 kL/day
- Calculation: 1,100 kL / 91 days = 12.08 kL/day
- Calculation: 1,000.5 kL / 91 days = 10.99 kL/day
Question 3:
On average, how many kilolitres of water did the service use daily in the previous year, in all four quarters separately?
- Calculation: 950 kL / 91 days = 10.43 kL/day
- Calculation: 550.5 kL / 91 days = 6.04 kL/day
- Calculation: 705.25 kL / 91 days = 7.75 kL/day
Fourth quarter:
- Calculation: 1762 kL / 91 days = 19.36 kL/day
Question 4:
Comparing the daily water usage for the first three quarters in the current and in the previous year, in which year did the service use more water and by how many kilolitres?
- In the current year, the service used 10.44 kL more water daily.
Calculation: 20.87 kL - 10.43 kL = 10.44 kL
Second quarter:
- In the current year, the service used 6.04 kL more water daily.
Calculation: 12.08 kL - 6.04 kL = 6.04 kL
Third quarter:
- In the current year, the service used 3.24 kL more water daily.
Calculation: 10.99 kL - 7.75 kL = 3.24 kL
Question 4:
If this year one (1) kilolitre is charged at $3.5, how much does the daily water usage cost for the service for each quarter?
- Calculation: 20.87 kL/day * $3.5 = $73.04/day
Second quarter:
- Calculation: 12.08 kL/day * $3.5 = $42.28/day
Third quarter:
- Calculation: 10.99 kL/day * $3.5 = $38.50/day
Question 5:
What tool did you use to perform the above calculations?
Question 6:
What factors should Ryan consider when estimating the cost of installing a rainwater harvesting system at EcoCare Co.?
- Initial costs: This includes the cost of the tank, installation, plumbing, and any necessary infrastructure modifications.
- Maintenance costs: Regular maintenance and possible repairs over time.
- Savings: Reduction in water bills over the long term.
- Environmental impact: Benefits to the environment and potential regulatory incentives or rebates.
- Legal compliance: Ensuring the system meets all local regulations and building codes.
Question 7:
List three short-term strategies that Jamie could implement immediately to reduce water consumption at EcoCare Co.
- Install low-flow fixtures: Replace standard faucets and showerheads with low-flow versions to reduce water use.
- Fix leaks promptly: Repair leaking taps, pipes, and toilets to prevent water wastage.
- Implement water-saving practices: Educate staff on water-saving techniques, such as turning off taps when not in use and using water-efficient dishwashing methods.
Question 8:
How would you engage Mia in the project and align her interest in sustainability and employee well-being with the goals of reducing water usage?
Once a service understands their environmental improvement needs, they will need to make a plan to minimise impact or improve systems.
First a goal, target or an environmental commitment needs to be set, along with strategies to achieve this goal and a realistic timeline for achievement.
An efficiency target can be to reduce consumption, reduce waste or reduce the service’s ecological footprint. Energy efficiency targets stimulates the development and implementation of efficiency strategies and policies.
SMART goals can be successful as they are evidence-based by requiring each goal to be:
|
|
|
|
|
---|---|---|---|---|
|
|
|
|
|
Be clear and specific so your goals are easier to achieve. This also helps you know how and where to get started! | Measurable goals can be tracked, allowing you to see your progress. They also tell you when a goal is complete. | Are you able to take action to achieve the goal? Actionable goals ensure the steps to get there are within your control. | Avoid overwhelm and unnecessary stress and frustration by making the goal realistic. | A date helps us stay focused and motivated, inspiring us and providing something to work towards. |
For example
A service may set the target to reduce their electricity bill. Their SMART goals would like this:
Reduce electricity consumption by 10% by the end of the quarter.
This is a specific, measurable, actionable and realistic goal that a service can achieve by setting clear procedures, such as replacing light fittings and lamps, maximise natural lights and replacing faulty appliances with energy efficient products.
The Plan, Do, Check, Act (PDCA) cycle is a system that supports the process of ensuring sustainability from beginning to end. This can help to make the journey one that is ongoing and has systematic processes and steps to achieve the results required.
The PDCA cycle involves:
To learn more about the impact of sustainability in the workplace watch the following 3-minute YouTube video by Recycle Coach:
When developing efficiency targets and goals, a service may consult a series of internal and external sources to better understand the options available.
Internal sources |
|
External sources | For ideas and recommendations:
|
Here are a few more resources
- View example goals and strategies on the AbsorbTech website
- View examples and templates for action plans on the Sustain Tool website
- Explore the City of Melbourne’s reporting and measuring tools here
Requirements for recording and filing documentation
Documentation should be recorded and filed in the organisation for a number of reasons such as:
- Compliance—To support legal requirements for audit purposes.
- Trend data—To identify any trends that are happening from previous times or years. This information can be used later and for conducting further analysis.
- To determine if the strategies implemented are effective.
Documentation may include and can give a business insight regarding:
- Cost effectiveness
- Usage of time
- Original objectives
- Communication techniques
- Legislation, regulations and standards
- Procedures and policies
- Effective communication
- Data recording
- Stakeholders
- Sufficient and accurate resources
- Support or training needs
- Integration with strategy
- Contingencies
Strategy implementation to achieve goals
Implementation is a large-scale system; it needs to be a concept of all in for the goals to be reached and achieved. Goals are supported by the collaboration of ideas, opinions and the voices of the stakeholders, especially those that will be implementing the strategies.
These stakeholders could include external or internal bodies and individuals, along with governing bodies. Involving team members with the work practice by supporting them to identify areas for improved resource efficiency will provide a wider range of ideas and encourage ownership.
Team members can support the process by:
- Assisting to measure current resource usage
- Suggesting alternative ideas and solutions to issues
- Implementing other strategies to improve resource usage
- Collaborating in the development of the Action Plan.
- Communicating and collaborating with stakeholders is key to successful sustainable goal planning and achievement. Therefore, workplaces should:
- Book regular meetings to discuss areas for improvement and the overall implementation plan
- Seek feedback throughout the cycle (the development and audit, after implementation and review)
- Decide on the actions they will take together with stakeholders.
You can seek further feedback from stakeholders by utilising:
- Surveys
- Questionnaires
- 1:1 Interviews
- Community forums
Case study
Implement energy saving practices Let’s say your goal is to reduce emissions and perhaps work towards zero emissions by 2030. This is abroad, large-scale goal that will have many moving parts. Most businesses will want to start slowly (most businesses will have around three to four goals at one time that they are working towards).
Let’s break this down and work on one area:
Energy efficiency
- Research strategies relevant to an education and care service. As examples, some generic strategies may include:
- Installing energy effect lighting, e.g. LED or automatic sensor lighting
- Using energy saving technology, e.g. desktops and monitor (LCD)
- Ensuring quality insulation or adding to insulation to minimise cost on heating and cooling, sealing any gaps or perhaps tinting windows
- Checking heating and cooling systems are set at reasonable levels, drop or turn off at night
- Considering which equipment uses more energy—Is there a reasonable alternative?
- How will you develop strategies (including how you will utilise and collaborate stakeholders) to achieve this? How will you measure it?
- Consult the template provided by the City of Melbourne (scroll to the relevant PDF)
- Switch off appliances when not in use.
- Set your thermostat to between 24 and 26 degrees for cooling in summer and between 18 and 20 degrees for heating in winter.
- Choose energy efficient alternatives when purchasing or leasing new equipment and appliances (anything that uses energy!).
- Minimise temperature leakages via good draught seals, insulation and keeping your doors closed.
- Run your service on renewables.
Change management
When new procedures are being developed, then implemented, staff can often show some level of resistance. This is due to the fact that changes in general can seem scary for some people and it may create uncertainty for some. Changes in daily practices can be interpreted as additional tasks and responsibilities that can be overwhelming for staff who are already stressed and overworked. Keep in mind that people are generally slow to adopt new habits, so allowing staff to adjust to change will give them a chance to familiarise themselves with the new way of doing things and gradually phase out old practices in a more natural way.
Therefore, whenever a service wants to implement new procedures, it is important to be aware of natural human reactions to change and proactively create strategies to make change as smooth as possible.
For successful change management, it is important to follow these four (4) principles:
- Understand change
- Plan change
- Implement change
- Communicate change
The following 8-minute YouTube video explains change management and its four (4) core principles:
Knowledge check
Resource
This article lists ten (10) best organizational change management strategies that can be implemented in an early childhood education and care setting.
This includes:
- planning carefully, outlining new or changing responsibilities for anyone affected, with fully-developed timelines and ready responses to address potential concerns
- being as transparent as possible, sharing pieces of information that can be shared with employees
- telling the truth without promising unrealistic outcomes
- open and respectful communication
- creating clear roadmaps to demonstrate the strategy behind the change
- providing training to ensure staff is prepared for the change and to avoid employees feeling like they'll be left behind due to lack of skill or experience
- inviting participation to allow employees to participate and/or provide feedback
- realistic expectations regarding the success and timeline of the process as people are generally slow to adopt new habits
- monitoring and measuring the implementation process to keep an eye on potential problems and address any issues in a timely manner
- demonstrating strong leadership by inspiring the team, demonstrating strategic thinking and being open-minded and flexible.
The benefit of collaborating with a team to implement sustainable work practices is that many hands make lightwork.
During the planning process, the workplace often develops a sustainability management team. This team is responsible for different areas of the program and support the education, implementation and monitoring of practices and strategies.
They are key investigators in observing whether the strategies:
- Are being implemented consistently by stakeholders
- Are successful.
The teams will return to the Action Plan within the agreed timeframe and compare measures. For example, with the energy efficiency goals, a measure may be energy bills and data from providers. You may look at, as an example, what the last quarter’s bill and readings were compared to after implementation of the goal or target. If this has improved the consumption of energy, it can be considered a success. From here, you could continue to modify and improve, or move on to a new goal.
It would be an opportunity and need for review and reflection when results demonstrate a lack of success and targets are not met by the timeline. The workplace must decipher why the goal has not been met or perhaps not as much as required.
You may reflect on whether:
- The timeline was too short for reaching the goal
- The strategies are not meeting the goal’s needs
- Stakeholders are not participating (so it is not being worked towards at all or enough to make an impact)
- The measurement method is not accurate or appropriate
- The goal designed is unachievable (this could be for various reasons).
Whether the goals have successfully been achieved or not, this information must be recorded for the service within the planning documentation. Over time, this may also be able to tell a story around why some areas are most successful than others (where this occurs).
Remember that this is an ongoing journey, cycle, and process that does not end.
There are always more goals to achieve, or raise the stakes to continue to minimise our carbon footprint and emissions as a business and in the world.
There are some useful resources that a service can use to collect information and compare data, this way monitoring (the effectiveness of) sustainable work practices:
Questionnaires and surveys |
|
Visual calculations, such as graphs and diagrams |
For example, it can be useful to create a diagram to compare a service’s energy expenses over a period of time. This will show clearly if expenses increased or decreased, and the amount of these changes. |
Supply records and invoices | Existing supply records and invoices allow to work out:
Supply records and invoices also establish a cost basis to compare. For example, it can be used to compare how much a service spends on resources. By identifying the exact costs, it is easier to identify where costs can be reduced for higher efficiency. |
Previous internal and external audit documents | Looking at previous audit documents gives a foundation or basis to compare the changes occurring from practices and to work on improving those practices. For example, a service’s assessment and rating outcome, including the assessor’s feedback, can be used to identify areas where improvements are needed for improving the service’s current work practices regarding sustainability. |
Here’s a brief example of a QIP:
Sustainability QIP | Month: October | ||
---|---|---|---|
What | Who | When | Notes |
Habitat/gardens | |||
Nesting box for birds or small animals | Ed leader & preschool | June 2022 | Complete |
Signage of plant names in the garden | Ed leader & preschool | July 2022 | Complete |
Indigenous food (bush tucker) garden | Ed, children & families | October 2022 | Complete |
Fruit trees | Ed, children & families | October 2022 | Complete |
Paper use | |||
Trays if tubs for re-using paper | All room leaders | May 2022 | Complete |
Energy and air quality audit | |||
Dry clothes on washing line outside | All room leaders | September 2022 | Complete |
Draft proof windows and doors | All educators, led by 21C | October 2022 | Complete |
Waste audit | |||
Paper/cardboard recycling | All room leaders | May 2022 | Complete |
Worm farm | Directors purchase ed | August 2022 | Complete |
Compost bin | Directors purchase ed | August 2022 | Complete |
Below you can access some more detailed examples of a Quality Improvement Plan (QIP). Look at the strengths and recommendations for Quality 3, Element 3.2.3.
Goal re-evaluation, modification and re-design
At this point of monitoring, the organisation will assess the success of the approach so far. If this needs to be amended or adjusted to achieve desired results, new strategies to achieve targets will need to be considered.
Questions you may ask when considering new strategies include:
- What is working?
- What is not working?
- Do we need to engage the team more to build better collaboration and participation in working towards these targets?
- Which strategies appear to be more successful?
- Can we implement similar strategies to better reach this goal or target?
With the use of organisational systems and procedures services, just like any other business, can develop effective environmental and resource sustainability improvements.
In the table below you can see a few examples of these organisational systems and procedures:
Supply chain, procurement and costing strategies | The development of supply chains is driven by measures like costs and customer service.
By considering the environmental constraints such as carbon taxes, emission trading schemes or green-house gas emissions to the supply chain the choice of the everyday practices is altered. The decision for procurement of product and/or services is often a trade-off between the economic and environmental performance measures. It is not always feasible for a business to commit to ensuring all practices will ensure maximum improvement in their environmental and resource sustainability due to the cost and time involved. For example, services often supply disposable nappies for children during their time at the service. Although reusable cloth nappies are more environment-friendly options, services often avoid their usage due to the additional time they would represent for staff. |
Quality assurance |
|
Recommendation development and seeking approvals |
|
Sales strategies and operations |
For example, a service should regularly review and monitor the enrolments to ensure the service meets its financial targets to provide the resources necessary for smooth operation. |
Case study
Let’s take a look at the following case study:
Step 1: A recent target of minimising waste in a service has proven ineffective. The strategies included:- Promotion verbally through meetings and visually through posters around the service
Step 2: The service saw no change. When the goal was reviewed, the service considered whether the timeline was too short. It was found to not be the issue. When the strategies were discussed with internal and external stakeholders, the feedback was that it was easily ignored or forgotten in their busy workdays. The service decided that more direct strategies were required to minimise waste.
Step 3: The committee designed the below strategies:
- Paper bins were removed, so that staff and children needed to recycle paper used
- Bins were delegated clearly as paper waste, food waste and recycling waste
- Educators were encouraged to work on projects with children to try to find creative solutions for reducing waste and how to recycle materials. Older children were involved in monitoring the correct use of bins.
Watch the following powerful 34-minute documentary by the United Nations about the urgent sustainability the world needs. It supports the concept that everyone needs to be involved.
Use the following questions to check your knowledge. You can check the correct answer by clicking on the 'Answer' button:
1. What is the PDCA cycle?
- Plan: Identify and understand the problem or opportunity. State the success criteria for the possible solution and make it measurable.
- Do: Test the solution with a small-scale pilot project. This shows if your proposed changes will achieve the desired outcomes. Gather data to see if the change has worked or not.
- Check: Analyse the data you have collected against the expectations that you defined in Plan. If it was a success, go to Act; if not, go back to Plan.
- Act: Implement the solution, remembering PDCA is a loop, not a process with a beginning and end. It is important to continue to look for ways to make it even better.
2. Why should the sustainability plan be documented?
- Compliance: To support legal requirements for audit purposes.
- Trend data: To identify any trends that are happening from previous times or years. This information can be used later and for conducting further analysis.
- To determine if the strategies implemented are effective.
3. How you can gather feedback from stakeholders about your organisation’s sustainability processes?
- Surveys
- Questionnaires
- 1:1 meetings
- Community forums.
Answer the following six (6) questions to check your understanding of this topic. Click the dots to navigate between the tasks.